Back Pain: When to Worry — ER vs Urgent Care vs Home Care
Learn when back pain requires emergency care, urgent care, or home treatment. Red flag symptoms including cauda equina syndrome, cost estimates, and recovery strategies.
Check my symptoms (free)
Fast, private, no sign-in.
Updated February 2026
Call 911 Immediately If You Have:
- Sudden loss of bladder or bowel control with back pain
- Progressive weakness or numbness in both legs
- Back pain after a major fall, car accident, or trauma
- Severe back pain with fever and chills
These may indicate cauda equina syndrome, spinal fracture, or spinal infection requiring immediate treatment.
On this page
Emergency Red Flags — Go to ER Now
Cauda Equina Syndrome (Emergency)
- • Loss of bladder or bowel control
- • Numbness in groin/inner thighs (saddle anesthesia)
- • Progressive weakness in both legs
- • Sexual dysfunction with back pain
Trauma-Related
- • Back pain after significant fall or impact
- • Pain after car accident (even minor)
- • Suspected spinal fracture
- • Pain with inability to move
Infection Signs
- • Back pain with fever and chills
- • Pain worse at night that wakes you
- • Localized severe tenderness over spine
- • Recent spinal procedure or injection
Cancer Warning Signs
- • Back pain with unexplained weight loss
- • History of cancer with new back pain
- • Pain that doesn't improve with rest
- • Night pain that is progressive and unrelenting
Time is critical: Cauda equina syndrome requires emergency surgery within hours to prevent permanent paralysis. Spinal infections and fractures also need urgent treatment.
When to See a Doctor (Same Day or Soon)
Persistent Pain
- • Pain lasting more than 4-6 weeks
- • Pain not improving with rest and OTC meds
- • Pain gradually worsening
- • Pain that disrupts sleep regularly
Nerve Symptoms
- • Pain radiating down one leg (sciatica)
- • Tingling or numbness in leg or foot
- • Weakness when lifting foot (foot drop)
- • Electric shock sensation with movement
Functional Impact
- • Unable to perform normal daily activities
- • Can't sit or stand for reasonable periods
- • Pain limiting work or exercise
- • Walking pattern affected
Timing Concerns
- • Sudden onset without clear cause
- • Pain after lifting heavy object not improving
- • Morning stiffness lasting more than 30 minutes (inflammatory)
- • First episode of back pain after age 50
What to Expect at Doctor Visit
Assessment
- • Neurological examination (reflexes, strength, sensation)
- • Range of motion testing
- • Straight leg raise test
- • Gait and posture evaluation
Possible Tests
- • X-ray (if fracture suspected)
- • MRI (if nerve compression suspected)
- • Blood tests (if infection or inflammation)
- • Referral to orthopedics or neurology
Best Place to Go — Quick Comparison
| Care Setting | When to Choose | Tests You'll Get | Typical Cost |
|---|---|---|---|
Emergency Room | Cauda equina signs, trauma/fracture, fever + back pain, progressive bilateral weakness. | MRI (emergent), CT scan, blood work, neurological assessment, surgical consult. | $1,000–$3,000+ Emergency imaging + surgery access |
Urgent Care | Acute strain with severe pain, mild sciatica, pain limiting mobility. | Physical exam, X-ray if available, pain management, muscle relaxant prescription. | $200–$500 Same-day evaluation |
Doctor (Primary Care) | Persistent pain 4+ weeks, sciatica, recurring episodes, post-injury follow-up. | Detailed exam, MRI referral, physical therapy referral, specialist referral. | $100–$250 Ongoing management |
Home Care | Mild muscle strain, post-exercise soreness, chronic low back pain (known), minor stiffness. | Rest, ice/heat, gentle stretching, OTC pain relief. | $5–$25 OTC medications |
Cost Disclaimer: Estimates are before insurance and vary by location, tests needed, and specific treatments.
Sources: Cost estimates based on CMS Provider Data, KFF Healthcare Cost Analysis, and national healthcare pricing databases.
Got a bill already? Our medical bill negotiation service can help reduce what you owe.
When Home Care Is Appropriate
Muscle Strain
Characteristics:
- • Clear cause (lifting, exercise, awkward movement)
- • Pain is muscular (not sharp or shooting)
- • No numbness, tingling, or weakness
- • Improving day by day
Chronic Low Back Pain
Can manage at home if:
- • Familiar pattern of symptoms
- • No new neurological symptoms
- • Responds to usual treatment
- • Maintaining daily activities
Effective Home Treatments
Immediate Relief
- • Ice for first 48 hours (20 min on/off)
- • Switch to heat after 48 hours
- • Gentle walking (avoid bed rest)
- • Comfortable sleeping position (pillow between knees)
Medications
- • Ibuprofen or naproxen (anti-inflammatory)
- • Acetaminophen for pain
- • Topical pain relievers (menthol, lidocaine)
- • Follow dosing instructions
Recovery
- • Gentle stretching daily
- • Core strengthening exercises
- • Maintain good posture
- • Gradual return to normal activity
When to Follow Up or Seek Care
Return to Doctor If:
- • Pain not improving after 4-6 weeks
- • New numbness or tingling developing
- • Weakness in legs or feet
- • Pain spreading down leg
- • Difficulty with daily activities
- • Pain worsening despite treatment
- • Fever or unexplained weight loss
- • Bladder or bowel changes
Frequently Asked Questions
What is cauda equina syndrome and why is it an emergency?
Cauda equina syndrome occurs when nerves at the base of the spinal cord are severely compressed. Warning signs include sudden loss of bladder or bowel control, numbness in the groin or inner thighs (saddle anesthesia), and progressive leg weakness. This is a surgical emergency — permanent paralysis can result if not treated within hours.
When should I go to the ER for back pain?
Go to the ER for back pain with loss of bladder or bowel control, progressive leg weakness or numbness, back pain after a major fall or accident, back pain with fever and chills (possible spinal infection), or back pain with unexplained weight loss. These symptoms may indicate conditions requiring emergency surgery or treatment.
How do I know if back pain is sciatica or something serious?
Sciatica causes pain radiating from the lower back down one leg, often with tingling or numbness. It typically improves with rest and conservative treatment over weeks. Seek emergency care if you have numbness in both legs, loss of bladder/bowel control, progressive weakness, or pain after trauma — these suggest a more serious nerve compression.
Do I need an MRI or X-ray for back pain?
Most back pain does not require imaging in the first 4-6 weeks unless red flag symptoms are present. Imaging is recommended for back pain with neurological symptoms (weakness, numbness), history of cancer, fever, trauma, or pain that worsens despite treatment. Your doctor will determine if imaging is needed based on your specific symptoms.
Get Personalized Care Guidance
Get the CareRoute app for personalized symptom assessment with provider recommendations, wait times, cost estimates, and tools to reduce medical bills.
Free for reasonable personal use